Walmart Plus vs Amazon Prime has been a hot comparison in my life lately, mostly because I’ve used both memberships side by side for months. At first, I just wanted faster shipping and maybe some grocery delivery. But along the way, I started noticing major differences that actually affected my day-to-day routine and my wallet.
I didn’t plan to compare them. I signed up for Walmart Plus during a grocery delivery promo, then kept my Amazon Prime going for its usual perks: two-day shipping, Prime Video, and the occasional Prime Day deal. But after a few weeks, I realized I was constantly weighing the pros and cons of each. Which one saved me more time? Which one gave me better extras? And, most importantly, which one actually gave me more value?
In this post, I’ll walk you through exactly what I found, based on real use, not just a feature list. From delivery speeds to entertainment perks and grocery convenience, here’s how Walmart Plus and Amazon Prime stack up in 2025.
Walmart Plus vs Amazon Prime – My Real-Life Experience Using Both
I’ve been using Walmart Plus and Amazon Prime at the same time for over three months now. Not because I wanted to run a comparison blog post, honestly, it just happened. I already had Prime (who doesn’t?), and I grabbed a free trial of Walmart Plus during a weekend grocery run. After that, I figured I’d keep both for a while and see which one actually made more sense for my lifestyle.
Why I Tried Both Memberships
I’m the kind of person who hates running last-minute errands. I love convenience, and if I can avoid store lines or traffic, I’m in. Amazon Prime has always been my go-to for quick deliveries, especially for household items or random tech. But grocery delivery? That’s where Walmart Plus came in strong.
I was curious to see how both services handled my everyday needs so I started using them side by side. I ordered the same categories from both, tested delivery times, and tracked how often I used their extra features like streaming or fuel discounts.
What Surprised Me Most About Walmart vs Amazon Services
The biggest surprise? Walmart’s same-day grocery delivery was way more reliable than I expected. Items were usually in stock, delivery windows were short, and prices were close to what I’d pay in-store. On the other hand, Amazon Prime’s strength was still in its variety—especially when I needed something super specific or hard to find.
But I also realized how little I used some Prime perks, like Amazon Music or the reading library. Meanwhile, Walmart’s fuel discounts and in-store pricing benefits added up faster than I thought.
In short, both memberships had their strengths but one clearly started to feel more useful in my daily life. I’ll get to that part later.
Delivery Speed Comparison – Walmart Plus vs Amazon Prime Shipping
When it comes to shipping speed, both Walmart Plus and Amazon Prime make bold promises—but real-world performance can tell a different story. Since I was using both memberships at the same time, I had the chance to compare their delivery services under the same roof.
Which One Actually Delivers Faster?
In my experience, Amazon Prime is still the winner for variety and fast shipping on non-grocery items. I could order a phone charger or a book at midnight and sometimes receive it the next day. Their two-day shipping is still consistent, and Prime Now (in cities where it’s available) can be incredibly fast.
But Walmart Plus impressed me more in the grocery department. I placed orders before noon and got everything delivered within a few hours—sometimes even faster. It felt like having a personal shopper. For regular household goods, Walmart wasn’t always as fast as Amazon, but it wasn’t far behind either. Some items came the next day; others took two days.
Where you live makes a big difference. In bigger cities, both services work like clockwork. But if you’re in a rural area, Amazon might have the edge thanks to its established logistics network.
So if your main goal is speed for everything under the sun—Amazon might be more reliable. But if you’re focused on grocery delivery and daily essentials, Walmart Plus holds its own surprisingly well.
Walmart Membership vs Amazon Prime – What Do You Really Pay?
One of the biggest deciding factors for me was cost. On the surface, both Walmart Plus and Amazon Prime seem similarly priced—but when I broke down the numbers, the value wasn’t as equal as I first thought.
Here’s a simple breakdown of what each membership costs in 2025:
| Feature | Walmart Plus | Amazon Prime |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Price | $98/year | $139/year |
| Monthly Price | $12.95/month | $14.99/month |
| Free Trial | 30 days | 30 days |
| Student Discount | Not available | Yes ($7.49/month) |
| EBT/Medicaid Discount | $6.47/month | Yes ($6.99/month) |
At first glance, Walmart Plus looks more affordable—especially if you go for the yearly plan. If you mainly use it for groceries, fuel discounts, and same-day delivery, it’s a solid deal.
Amazon Prime is more expensive, but it includes a wider range of extras like streaming services, cloud storage, and early access to sales. If you take full advantage of those perks, the price feels justified. But if you’re only using it for deliveries, you might be overpaying.
I found myself using Walmart Plus more frequently for everyday needs, while some Prime perks felt underused. So even though Amazon charges more, the value you get really depends on what you actually use.
Walmart Plus vs Prime Perks
One thing I didn’t expect was how different the perks actually felt once I started using both memberships. On paper, they each offer a lot but in practice, some benefits stood out more than others depending on what I actually needed.
With Walmart Plus, the in-store fuel discounts, mobile scan-and-go, and free grocery delivery became part of my weekly routine. I didn’t realize how convenient it was to shop for groceries online and have them dropped off within a few hours without extra delivery fees. The fuel savings were small each time, but they added up quickly.
Amazon Prime, on the other hand, had its strength in entertainment. I used Prime Video almost every night, and the included Amazon Music and reading perks were a nice bonus. Also, having early access to deals, especially during Prime Day was a real plus for tech and holiday shopping.
Still, I found myself ignoring some Prime features. I didn’t really use Amazon Photos or the gaming bonuses, while Walmart’s fewer perks were more directly useful. It’s really a matter of lifestyle. If you want more features, Prime gives you variety. If you want practical, everyday perks, Walmart Plus keeps things simple but effective.
Amazon Prime vs Walmart Plus for Grocery Delivery
Grocery delivery was one of the main reasons I tried both memberships in the first place. With a busy schedule and little patience for grocery store lines, I was curious which service would truly make my life easier.
Walmart Grocery Experience – Freshness, Timing, and Fees
Walmart Plus made grocery shopping surprisingly easy. I could place an order in the morning and receive everything by early afternoon. Most of the items were in stock, and the substitutions (if needed) were usually better than expected. The Walmart grocery delivery team also allowed me to tip and communicate through the app, which made things smoother.
The best part? No delivery fees. As long as I met the order minimum (usually around $35), I didn’t have to pay anything extra. For someone who orders groceries weekly, this saved me at least $10–15 per week.
Amazon Fresh vs Walmart Pickup – My Weekly Routine
Amazon Fresh was decent but felt a bit clunky. The app layout wasn’t as intuitive, and sometimes delivery slots were full unless I booked a day ahead. I also noticed that certain essentials, especially produce or dairy, were more likely to be out of stock. While the Amazon Fresh service worked, it didn’t feel as dependable as Walmart’s setup.
I tried Walmart’s pickup option too, and honestly, it was just as good as delivery. I’d select a time, pull up, and they’d load everything into my trunk within minutes. Between Amazon Fresh and Walmart pickup, I started leaning heavily toward Walmart especially for weekly shopping.
Final Verdict – Walmart Plus or Amazon Prime in 2025?
After using both memberships side by side for months, I can say this: there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It really comes down to your lifestyle and what you care about most.
If fast shipping, a wide selection of products, and access to movies, music, and special sales matter to you Amazon Prime still delivers a strong all-around package. It’s more expensive, but if you use all the extras, the value adds up.
On the other hand, if your main priorities are grocery delivery, fuel savings, and practical everyday perks, then Walmart Plus might actually be the better fit. It’s more affordable, simpler to use, and surprisingly efficient—especially for families or people who already shop at Walmart often.
As for me? I didn’t cancel either right away. But over time, I found myself using Walmart Plus more frequently for day-to-day needs. Prime still has a place in my life, but it feels more like a luxury. Walmart Plus feels like a tool.
So if you’re deciding between the two, ask yourself: Do I want variety or efficiency? Entertainment or essentials? That answer will probably lead you to the right membership for 2025.